英国最好私校之一的校长批评“扫雪机父母“snowplough parent

以前说有pushy parents(虎妈狼爸),现在又出现个新说法“snowplough parents”(扫雪机父母),就是parents clear all obstacles for children(为孩子清除一切障碍不让孩子输在跑线上的父母)。

St Paul女校校长攻击这类校长,说很多父母有怕孩子得不了第一的焦虑症。

Top head attacks pushy ‘snowplough’ parents
Clarissa Farr, head of St Paul’s Girls’ School in west London, said that many parents showed a “frenetic anxiety” and refused to accept their child coming second

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/11262228/Top-head-attacks-pushy-snowplough-parents.html

Parents of children attending Britain’s top fee paying schools are terrified how their children’s failure will reflect on themselves, one of the country’s top head teachers has said.

Clarissa Farr, head of St Paul’s Girls’ School in west London, also accused successful parents of “affluent neglect” - not paying their children enough attention in the evenings.

Mrs Farr said that many parents showed a “frenetic anxiety” and refused to accept their child coming second. She warned that children were growing up unable to cope with failure as a result, the Times reported.

“Their children will succeed above all and they’re not at all on board with the idea of school as a community, learning to come second or that learning to give ground is an important part of education,” she told a workshop at the Girls’ Schools Association conference this week.

Mrs Farr’s school charges up to £22,500 a year. Entry is by competitive examination and interview, and the school says it encourages high standards of achievement.

She said: “Parents have very high aspirations — they have a kind of ticking, frenetic anxiety — even the ones who are delightful to deal with are on edge because they haven’t really got enough time to have the conversation they’re trying to have with you.

“Anything that might result in success not happening for their son or daughter, in however small an arena, they’re very frightened of.”

Such “snowplough” parents cleared all obstacles from their children’s path and tried to boost their self-esteem at all costs, Mrs Farr added. Their children were left over-protected and unable to cope with failure.

Some parents saw school as a “bespoke, consumer service”. She said: “Again at the more extreme ends I’ve certainly noticed an increase in the expectation among parents that what is arranged for their daughter will be specific and bespoke. If she happens to speak a language that you don’t offer, it will be expected that you provide appropriate tuition. Something that shocked me quite a lot, and I’ve seen it more in the last few years, is the naked impatience with the idea of putting other people first that you see coming from parents. I think that’s a growing trend among city parents who have a sort of Darwinian attitude to their children’s education.”

This summer 57 per cent of A levels taken at St Paul’s Girls’ School were graded A*, as were 94 per cent of GCSEs, and 99 per cent of GCSEs were A* or A.

Mrs Farr’s comments come after Tristram Hunt, the shadow education secretary, attacked private schools for not doing enough to help state school pupils, and threatened to remove their business rate relief. He asked in an interview with The Times published on Saturday why private schools should be “subsidised” if they are “increasingly just taking rich foreigners and doing nothing to help children here”.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-2733084/Parents-clear-obstacle-offsprings-path-inadvertently-ruin-lives.html

教育专家说:Why being a ‘snowplough parent’ could HARM your child: Mothers and fathers who clear every obstacle in their offspring’s path risk making them ‘anxious and dependent’

Most of us are familiar with the concept of the ‘helicopter parent’ who hovers anxiously over their child’s every move.

But now a new parenting type has been identified - and experts say ‘snowplough parents’, who clear every obstacle from their child’s path while piling on the pressure to achieve, can be every bit as damaging.

According to David McCullough, a teacher for 30 years and the author of a book on the subject, aggressive parenting is producing children who are ‘anxious, dependent, narcissistic and careerist’.

Speaking to the Sunday Times, he also warned that children are becoming ‘terrified of failure’ and being turned into ‘achievement machines’ by their parents.

‘From birth, they are strapped into the car seat and protected, driven and aimed in one direction,’ he added.

‘They [children] are compliant; they have given up self-determination and a willingness to explore their own interests.’

And the results of competitive parenting, from failure to settle into careers to dependence and even breakdown, can be devastating.

Not, says McCullough, that any of this is intended. ‘If you do not get into one of the top 30 to 50 colleges, you are in for a very hard time in life - that’s the thinking driving all this,’ he explains.

Snowplough parenting is becoming increasingly common in the UK as well as the US with nearly a quarter of teenagers supplied with tutors by their parents in a bid to boost their grades.

After school classes, intensive music lessons and an emphasis on besting the competition in team sports are all favourites of the snowplough parent, who also, on occasion, take charge of their children’s homework.

As a result of increasing parental pressure, one in 10 university students suffers from mental health problems while others find themselves unable to cope without help from Mum and Dad and an army of private tutors.

‘They besiege professors for extra lessons or expect a private tutor like they had when they were 17,’ explains McCullough.

‘In some cases, they just drop out, seeing failure as a failure of the support system around them and not as their failure.’

This, he argues in his new book You Are Not Special, has arisen from the modern ‘cult of exceptionalism’ and which has made children afraid to be average.

In it, he highlights examples of snowplough parenting, including that of a child being sent on a 120-mile bus journey every Saturday for a piano lesson and another who, when confronted with spelling mistakes by his teacher, replied: ‘Mum must have missed those.’

Instead of succumbing to the temptation to micromanage children, McCullough says that parents should try taking a step back.

‘Try as much as possible to give children free rein,’ he advises. 'Let them follow their own passions and curiosities without overweening interference every step of the way.

‘Sometimes our kids take paths they shouldn’t, sometimes they will make mistakes. That’s OK.’

You Are Not Special: And Other Encouragements by David McCullough costs £11.46 and is published by Scribe
Read more: ‘Snowplough parents’ can ruin children’s lives

多谢分享

顶一下。

children are like mirrors, reflecting both the good and bad aspects of their parents’ personality.

可怜天下父母心,中国英国都一样。:stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye:

St Paul女校以培养Alpha Female出门,家长大部分都是很有钱的“成功人士”,校长难当可以理解。另外St Paul的女孩名声在外,是所有私校女生里面最nasty的,当然名声不一定是truth。

---------
话说education成为service以后当老师越来越难了,大学自从交高学费以后老师越来越难当了,National Student Union现在要求他们要进入大学的appointment和promotion的committee并且要求有veto的权利。:cn14:

对啊,大学口号竟然是“学生是我们的顾客”。。。

老师难当,大不了不教科专门搞科研。可是中学老师就惨了。

{:5_143:}

有翻译吗。。。

帮忙顶,也顺便学习了。

This summer 57 per cent of A levels taken at St Paul’s Girls’ School were graded A*, as were 94 per cent of GCSEs, and 99 per cent of GCSEs were A* or A.
冲着这个俺都想送女儿去了, 不过估计人家未必