私校学生好在什么地方?看看这份研究报告!

现如今什么都有人研究,弄些数据统计分析一下就可以按照自己的想法搞篇文章,真是叫兽砖家满天飞啊!

Private school children are tougher than their state educated peers, study finds
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/2017/01/18/private-school-children-tougher-state-educated-peers-study-finds/
"Emotional intelligence, reaction to failure, leadership, perseverance, resilience and the ability to improvise and adapt on one’s feet are increasingly important"Mark Mortimer, Headmaster of Warminster School

Private school children are tougher than their state educated counterparts, a study has found. New research commissioned by the Independent Schools Council (ISC) found that pupils at fee-paying schools are more controlled, committed and confident than those who went to state schools.

The study, titled An Analysis of Mental Toughness at UK Independent Schools, involved 9,000 pupils of all ages from 58 schools in England and Scotland. It measured four categories: control, commitment, challenge and confidence.

Julie Robinson, General Secretary of ISC, said that privately educated students scored better due to “the breadth of curriculum, wide-ranging activities outside the classroom and excellent pastoral care” which she said helps to create “create resilient and worldly young men and women who are ready for further study and work in adult life."

The psychometric test publisher AQR found that private school children have good attainment, wellbeing and behaviour and are more resilient, better at dealing with setbacks and more open to learning as a result. This test, which defines mental toughness as the ‘mindset that every person adopts in everything they do’ gave an overall score of 4.26 for privately educated students,while state school children had a score of 3.94.

Mark Mortimer, Headmaster of Warminster School, a day and boarding school in Wiltshire, whose pupils took part in the study, said: "Of course, exam results matter, but not as much as the qualities that allow pupils to leave school able to thrive, both professionally and personally, in the fluid, ever-changing and let-go world of the 21st century.

“Emotional intelligence, reaction to failure, leadership, perseverance, resilience and the ability to improvise and adapt on one’s feet are increasingly important."

Peter Clough, Professor of Applied Psychology at Manchester Metropolitan University, who moderated the process and analysis of the research, said: “It seems a strong focus on confidence building is not sufficient to develop the rounded life skills schools could usefully be looking elsewhere, on areas such as emotion, goals and facing setback.

“Schools might usefully look at developing complementary areas such as emotional control, managing goals and aspirations and showing pupils that they can learn from their setbacks as well as their successes.”

“more controlled, committed and confident ”这些都是私校明显的优势。但也有人说私校孩子被保护得太好,不知道生活艰辛和社会复杂。不好说哪个更好,还是挑适合孩子的吧。

私校学生应该是有这些优势的,但我觉得这些优势是来自家庭不是来自学校。

不知道这个research用的公校是什么公校,如果用公立grammar school学生做对比,结论可能就不一样了。

学校和学生相互的关系,学生愿意学习,老师维持记录的时间就短些,花在学习上的时间也更多。送私校很大一部分家长对孩子教育比较重视,当然不排除认为孩子需要更多关注而送私校的,自然会在培养孩子上多花时间。Grammar不错,但是否达到同比例优质私校的水平就见仁见智了。

我也觉得上私校的学生的家庭环境决定了他们的能力强。真正拼的是爹娘,而不是学校本身。

我只能说 上课纪律相对来说 私校好很多

绝对同意这点,孩子们上学时间其实不长,剩下的不管是进club也好兴趣班也好,都是家长们在使劲。反正我们这儿的私校里面,有些确实好(但是具体来自学校还是家庭的作用就很难说),有些里面的学生就是玩玩玩,have fun,一直到毕业也没见到有什么career 上的发展。对私校不能一言概之。

不论是公/私校, 都需要家长们在使劲。

家庭影响肯定更大一些,私校的一些优势更多是起到锦上添花的作用